United Airlines vs. American Airlines, Which one is better?

When it comes to choosing between United Airlines and American Airlines, you’re faced with a tough decision. Both airlines have their strengths and weaknesses, boasting various amenities and services.

In this comparative analysis, we’ll investigate into the nitty-gritty of what each airline has to offer. From in-flight comfort to customer service, baggage policies to frequent flyer programs, we’re leaving no stone unturned.

So, are you ready to find out which airline suits your travel needs best? Buckle up, as we embark on this journey to determine whether United Airlines or American Airlines takes the crown in the aviation industry.

In-flight comfort

When comparing United Airlines and American Airlines, in-flight comfort takes center stage. It’s one of the main factors that you, as a traveler, consider for your journey.

Let’s investigate into the details.

United Airlines: A Dedication to Comfort

United Airlines has pulled all stops in ensuring maximum in-flight comfort. They’ve redesigned their cabins, optimizing for more space and better seating. Whether you’re flying economy or first class, these upgrades aim to enhance your flying experience.

United also offers an impressive variety of in-flight entertainment. From recent movie releases to popular TV shows, your flight will hardly be a bore. Also, they’ve streamlined meal services to include a variety of cuisines to meet your dietary preferences and needs.

American Airlines: Pioneering Relaxation in the Skies

Moving on to American Airlines, they’ve invested greatly in their premium cabins, especially in transcontinental flights. Amenities include lay-flat seats and direct aisle access, making for a stellar in-flight experience. The onboard Wi-Fi service is robust for those who can’t go off-grid.

American Airlines doesn’t fall short in the entertainment department either. They offer a range of options from live TV to music and gaming. With their improved meal services, you’re in for a treat!

In terms of laying comparisons on the table, it’s worth noting that both United and American have tried to outdo one another in steering a luxurious yet relaxed environment for their passengers.

But as always, the choice of airline depends on your individual needs and preferences. So, is it the redesigned cabins of United Airlines or the premium offerings from American Airlines that draws you in? Remember, no matter which you choose, your comfort is the priority.

Customer service

When you’re tackling the tough decision of United Airlines vs American Airlines, customer service often tips the scales. As a customer, outstanding service forms the crux of your flying experience. Let’s sail through the customer service landscape of these two airlines.

United Airlines has been applauded for its stellar customer service. Their staff is trained to handle a variety of situations ensuring that your experience from booking to deboarding is smooth. United’s “core4” service model underlines safety, caring, dependability, and efficiency, which continually sets them apart.

Have you lost luggage before? United’s automated “baggage tracker” system reassures passengers about their luggage’s location from departure to arrival. This airline doesn’t just say it; they prove it, landing themselves a good spot with customers.

On to American Airlines. They’re no strangers to top-tier customer service, either. This airline emphasizes creating a comfortable and hassle-free travel experience for each passenger. With a customer service plan that boasts transparency from fees and ticketing policies to baggage handling and delay management, they certainly cater to comfort-conscious travelers.

American’s “Remember Me” program takes personalized service to new heights. This innovative initiative extends personalized services to frequent flyers, making them feel valued. They also have a 24/7 helpline that serves as an effective tool for addressing passenger concerns promptly.

Both airlines strive to offer the best service, keeping your comfort at the forefront. With continuous efforts to enhance their interaction with passengers, United and American Airlines go the extra mile to ensure you are content throughout your journey.

Given the above, it’s clear that customer service is a top priority for both United and American Airlines. So, the next time you’re in the sky, sit back, relax and enjoy the empathetic and considerate service that these airlines promise to offer. The choice, eventually, is yours.

Baggage policies

Navigating the labyrinth of airline baggage policies can feel like a challenging job, but we’re here to simplify it for you. We’ll compare the baggage policies of both United Airlines and American Airlines to give you a clear picture.

United Airlines has a pretty straightforward baggage policy. Passengers are allowed the ‘one-bag carry-on, one personal item’ rule. The maximum dimensions for a carry-on bag are 9 inches x 14 inches x 22 inches. Checked bags can’t exceed 50lbs for Economy and 70lbs for Business and First class passengers. Pricing for additional baggage and overweight or oversized luggage varies based on flight destination and ticket type. Changes to their policy incorporated an automated baggage tracker system, providing passengers the assurance their luggage is accounted for.

On the other hand, American Airlines also sticks to the ‘one carry-on bag and one personal item’ rule, echoing the size limits of United Airlines for carry-on luggage. For checked in luggage, they mirror the 50lbs weight limit for Economy, but allow a greater weight of 100lbs for Business and First class. But, American Airlines’ baggage pricing varies quite a bit based on destination, flight duration, and ticket class.

If you’re a frequent traveler, it might be beneficial to take note of their respective reward programs. United’s MileagePlus and American’s AAdvantage program offer extra baggage allowances to their members, among other perks.

Refer to the table below for some quick comparative stats:

Carry-on Bag 9 x 14 x 22 in 9 x 14 x 22 in
Personal Item 1 1
Checked Bag Weight Limit (Economy) 50 lbs 50 lbs
Checked Bag Weight Limit (Business and First Class) 70 lbs 100 lbs

So, to navigate these policies, always size and weigh your luggage before you leave for the airport. Unexpected baggage fees can sneak up on you if you’re not careful!
Review every airline’s baggage policy when making your choice as each one is different and may fit better depending on your traveling needs.

Frequent flyer programs

Let’s shift our focus now to another crucial aspect of air travel – frequent flyer programs. After all, everyone likes to get a little more for their money.

United Airlines offers the MileagePlus program. You can earn miles not just from flights but also through their various partners which include hotels, rental car companies, and restaurants. The best part is, there’s no expiration on these miles as long as you’re an active participant. For every dollar you spend on flights, you earn at least five miles. Also, as a MileagePlus member, you also have access to exclusive mileage redemption opportunities.

Status Level Additional Benefits
Premier Silver 7 miles per dollar, free checked bag
Premier Gold 8 miles per dollar, two free checked bags
Premier Platinum 9 miles per dollar, three free checked bags
Premier 1K 11 miles per dollar, three free checked bags

On the other hand, American Airlines offer AAdvantage as their loyalty program. This program also features a range of partners for earning purposes, but its unique selling point is the wide network of international airlines under the One World Alliance. No worry about your miles expiring here either, you just need to fly once in 18 months. As an AAdvantage member, you get a minimum of five miles per dollar for your flights.

Status Level Additional Benefits
Gold 7 miles per dollar, free checked bag
Platinum 8 miles per dollar, one free checked bag
Platinum Pro 9 miles per dollar, two free checked bags
Executive Platinum 11 miles per dollar, three free checked bags

The choice between the two becomes a matter of personal preferences and travel habits. Consider your destinations, the partnerships each airline has, and how fast you want to pile up those miles. Choosing the right program can be a game-changer in the world of air travel. Whether you choose United Airline’s MileagePlus or American Airline’s AAdvantage, you’ll be reaping the rewards of smart travel decisions.


After examining both United and American Airlines, it’s clear that each has its strengths. United’s MileagePlus program offers flexibility with earning miles, while American’s AAdvantage program boasts a broad network of international partners. Your preference between the two hinges on your travel habits and desired rewards. The verdict? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It’s about finding the airline that best suits your needs. So, whether you value in-flight comfort, customer service, or baggage policies, both airlines offer compelling options. Eventually, the choice is yours. Choose wisely and make every mile count!

What is the main focus of the article?

The article primarily compares United Airlines and American Airlines in terms of in-flight comfort, customer service, baggage policies, and frequent flyer programs.

What are the frequent flyer programs offered by the airlines?

United Airlines offers the MileagePlus program, while American Airlines provides the AAdvantage program. Both allow passengers to earn miles that can be redeemed later.

How can miles be earned in the MileagePlus program?

In the MileagePlus program, passengers not only earn miles from flights but also through various partners of United Airlines.

Which airlines are part of the AAdvantage program?

The AAdvantage program features a network of international airlines under the One World Alliance, alongside American Airlines.

What additional benefits do the frequent flyer programs offer?

Both MileagePlus and AAdvantage offer different status levels which come with additional benefits. Free checked bags is one of the notable benefits offered.

How should I choose between MileagePlus and AAdvantage?

Your choice between MileagePlus and AAdvantage should depend on your personal preferences, travel habits, and the rewards you prioritize.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent post

Table of Contents

Scroll to Top