Which Is Better Between American Airlines and Southwest?

When it comes to choosing between American Airlines and Southwest, it’s not a simple black and white decision. You’re likely asking yourself, “Which airline is going to offer me the best value for my money?” or “Which one will provide the best overall experience?”.

In this text, we’ll investigate into the nitty-gritty details of both airlines. We’ll compare their services, rewards programs, and customer satisfaction ratings. By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which airline is the better choice for your specific needs. So, buckle up and get ready for an in-depth comparison that’ll help you make an well-informed choice.

Services Offered

When you analyze the services offered by both airlines, American Airlines and Southwest, there are some significant differences to note. You need these details to decide which airline suits your traveling needs better.

American Airlines offers three main cabin classes – Economy, Business, and First Class. If you’re traveling for business or need extra comfort, these options have a lot to give. You get more legroom, premium dining options, and even access to an exclusive airport lounge. It’s all about enhancing your flight experience.

Let’s make a shift to Southwest Airlines. They take a different approach to service. Southwest has a single cabin class, but don’t be quick to disregard them. The airline does its best to create a comfortable and enjoyable flight experience for all passengers. In-flight benefits include two free checked bags, Wi-Fi availability, and even free live TV on most flights. Southwest’s perks create a value-loaded package wrapped in simplicity.

Here’s a comparison of the services between the two airlines:

Service American Airlines Southwest Airlines
Main Cabin Classes Economy, Business, First Single Class
Checked Bag Fees Yes, varies by class No, first two bags free
In-Flight Entertainment Yes, varies by class Yes, Free Live TV
Wi-Fi Yes, fees associated Yes, $8 per day

Understanding these service offerings gives a clear picture of what you’re signing up for. It helps you understand the value you’re getting for your hard-earned money. It’s critical to assess what amenities and services are non-negotiable for your travel. Other factors such as the frequency of flights, routes, and airfare also affect your airline choice. All these details help you make an well-informed choice about American Airlines and Southwest Airlines.

Rewards Programs

A major factor in your airline choice should be loyalty or “rewards” programs. Let’s take a closer look at what American Airlines and Southwest have to offer in this sphere.

American Airlines’ rewards program is known as AAdvantage. With AAdvantage, you earn miles based on the distance you travel. Rewards are plentiful: from flight upgrades to vacation packages, retail products to car rentals. Let’s not forget that you’re able to use these miles for flights with American Airlines and other OneWorld partners.

A key perk that sets American Airlines apart is the elite status tiers in the AAdvantage program. There are four tiers: Gold, Platinum, Platinum Pro, and Executive Platinum. Each level offers increasing benefits like priority boarding, free checked bags, and seat upgrades. Your dedicated efforts can help you climb the ladder, earning more significant rewards in the process.

Contrastingly, Southwest’s Rapid Rewards program is revenue-based, which means you gain points based on how much the ticket costs rather than the distance traveled. The simplicity and straightforwardness of this approach appeal to many, making it less confusing to know how many points you’re actually earning.

Unlike American Airlines, Southwest does not offer tiered status within its rewards program but it does have a Companion Pass. This coveted pass allows customers who have flown 100 qualifying one-way flights or earned 125,000 qualifying points in a calendar year to select one person to fly free with them for the following complete calendar year.

Also, these points don’t expire as long as you make at least one purchase every 24 months. Southwest promotes reward exchange too, allowing you to use points for car rentals, hotels, and even for purchasing gift cards.

Each airline’s rewards program has its own strengths and singularities. If you’re eyeing a program rich in status tiers and international compatibility, then American Airlines might be a good fit. For those who appreciate clear, simple earning structures and domestic travel bonuses, Southwest’s Rapid Rewards could hold more appeal.

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Take your own traveling habits and preferences into account as you weigh these options.

Customer Satisfaction Ratings

Diving deeper into our comparison, let’s look at the often crucial aspect of customer satisfaction ratings. How do American Airlines and Southwest stack up against each other in terms of customer happiness? Remember, satisfied customers commonly indicate a better overall flight experience.

American Airlines holds its ground with favorable customer ratings. According to the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), American Airlines scored 73 out of a possible 100 points in 2020. Their customers praise them for their professional staff, cleanliness, and the variety of flight schedules.

On the other hand, Southwest is a heavy hitter when it comes to customer scores. Outperforming many competitors, Southwest scored an exceptional 80 out of 100 in the same ACSI survey. Frequent Southwest flyers often compliment the airline’s customer service, punctuality, and the added value of the Rapid Rewards program.

Here’s a quick breakdown of the aforementioned data:

Airline ACSI Score (2020)
American Airlines 73
Southwest 80

From these ratings, it’s clear that both airlines excel in different areas that influence customer satisfaction. While American Airlines receives praise for its variety of flight options and cleanliness, Southwest seems to stand out with superior customer service and timeliness. Differences aside, it’s obvious both airlines are committed to delivering a good overall experience – a testament to their high scores.

With this in mind, your flight choice might eventually be more about preference. Are you willing to trade more flight options for punctual service? Or does earning rewards hold a higher value for you? These are questions only you can answer.

As we continue our comparison journey, keep these satisfaction ratings in mind. They could make all the difference when deciding between American Airlines and Southwest for your next trip.

Comparison of Prices

Let’s investigate into a critical deciding factor: prices. Comparing the prices between American Airlines and Southwest isn’t as straightforward as you might think.

American Airlines utilizes a traditional tiered pricing structure. You’re likely to see a broad price range for flights, influenced by factors like the time of booking, travel class, and flight timing. At times, their price tags might appear steep, especially for last-minute bookings or high-demand routes.

You’d be surprised by their budget-friendly Basic Economy fares, perfect for the frugal travelers who don’t mind sacrificing some perks.

Here’s a simple representation of American Airlines’ fare structure:

Fare Type Perks
Basic Economy Cheapest fare, Limited Perks
Main Cabin Moderate Fare, More Perks
Business / First Class Highest Fare, Most Perks

Switch your attention to Southwest, and you’ll notice a significantly different pricing approach. They’ve built their reputation around their unique single-class service and the Transfarency policy – their commitment to providing low fares sans hidden fees. So, Southwest offers one class service with three fare categories: Wanna Get Away, Anytime, and Business Select.

Southwest prices and their perks look something like this:

Fare Type Perks
Wanna Get Away Lowest Fare, Basic Perks
Anytime Higher Fare, Added Perks
Business Select Highest Fare, Maximum Perks

Summarizing, while American Airlines’ offers might seem pricier, they also provide various fare classes and service. Southwest, on the other hand, emphasizes simplicity and transparency with competitive pricing and no hidden fees. So, depending on what matters to you more – service variety or straightforward pricing – it’s down to your preferences.


Choosing between American Airlines and Southwest boils down to what matters most to you. If you’re seeking versatility in ticket pricing and service levels, American Airlines’ tiered pricing structure might be more up your alley. But if transparency and simplicity in pricing without hidden fees are your top priorities, you can’t go wrong with Southwest’s straightforward fare categories. Remember, it’s about finding the right fit for your travel needs and budget. Whether that’s American Airlines or Southwest, the choice is eventually yours.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the pricing structure for American Airlines?

American Airlines uses a tiered pricing structure influenced by various factors such as booking in advance, travel class, and flight timing. The fares range widely in pricing but also include Basic Economy fares for budget-conscious travelers.

Do Southwest Airlines have different fare categories?

Yes, Southwest Airlines offers only one class of service, but with three fare categories: ‘Wanna Get Away’, ‘Anytime’, and ‘Business Select’. Each category has different benefits and pricing.

Can I find hidden fees in Southwest Airlines’ pricing?

No, one of Southwest Airlines’ commitments is to maintain transparency in their pricing. So you won’t find any hidden fees.

Does American Airlines offer a basic economy fare?

Yes, American Airlines does offer a budget-friendly Basic Economy fare for frugal travelers.

Which airline should I choose between American Airlines and Southwest based on fare classes and service?

The choice between American Airlines and Southwest Airlines primarily depends on your individual preference. If you prefer variety in fare classes and service, you may favor American Airlines. But if you value simplicity and straightforward pricing, Southwest would be the better choice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent post

Table of Contents

Scroll to Top